Case Details

Decision Information

Decision Content

NOTE: Some of the documents on this web page have been provided by external sources and have been inserted, as received, in the language and format of record.
Questions or comments may be sent by e-mail to:
tribunal@ct-tc.gc.ca

 

CT-2016-015 ( Vancouver Airport Authority )

 

Proceeding 1

The Commissioner of Competition v. Vancouver Airport Authority

Section(s):

79 - Abuse of dominant position

Filed on:

2016-09-29

Status:

Decided - 2019-10-17

 

Applicant(s):

The Commissioner of Competition

Respondent(s):

Vancouver Airport Authority

 

Hearing Date:

October 2, 3, 4, 5, 9, 10, 15, 16, 17, 30, 2018
November 1, 2, 13, 14 ,15, 2018
August 12, 13, 14, 2019

Hearing Location:

Ottawa and Vancouver

Panel Members:

Crampton C.J.

Gascon J.

Dr. Donald McFetridge

 

Case Documents

 

Pleading(s)

 

#

Title

Date

2

Notice of Application

2016-09-29

10

Response

2016-11-14

14

Reply

2016-11-28

42

Response to Respondent's motion

2017-03-07

49

Memorandum of fact and law on behalf of the Commissioner of Competition

2017-03-17

51

Memorandum of fact and law on behalf of Vancouver Airport Authority

2017-03-17

59

Updated memorandum of fact and law on behalf of Vancouver Airport Authority

2017-03-21

60

Supplemental memorandum of fact and law on behalf of the Applicant

2017-03-27

61

Supplemental submissions on behalf of the Respondent

2017-03-27

84

Commissioner of Competition's response to Respondent's notice of motion

2017-05-15

85

Commissioner's memorandum of fact and law regarding the Vancouver Airport Authority's motion challenging the adequacy and accuracy of summaries

2017-05-24

87

Memorandum of fact and law of the Vancouver Airport Authority regarding the motion challenging adequacy and accuracy of summaries

2017-05-24

93

Memorandum of fact and law of the Respondent

2017-06-06

104

Memorandum of fact and law re: motion challenging the adequacy and accuracy of summaries

2017-06-22

107

Memorandum of fact and law (Supplementary motion record) of the Applicant re: motion challenging the adequacy and accuracy of summaries

2017-06-23

109

Affidavit of Ryan Cookson re: motion challenging the adequacy and accuracy of summaries

2017-06-26

127

Motion record in response

2017-10-10

132

Commissioner's memorandum of fact and law

2017-10-12

137

Expert report of Dr. Gunnar Niels

2017-11-15

141

Affidavit of Dr. Gunnar Niels

2017-11-16

190

Expert report of Dr. David Reitman

2018-02-14

225

Amended response of VAA

2018-04-18

322

Memorandum of fact and law of the Respondent

2018-09-10

340

Applicant memo of fact and law

2018-09-19

346

Agreed statement of facts

2018-09-24

A-082

Expert report of Dr. Gunnar Niels

2018-10-15

R-098

Supplementary expert report of Dr. David Reitman

2018-10-16

R-133

Supplementary expert report of Dr. Michael W. Tretheway

2018-10-31

385

Closing argument of VAA

2018-11-09

397

Closing submissions of the Commissioner

2018-11-09

 

Decision(s)

 

#

Title

Date

20

Direction scheduling a CMC on December 20, 2016

2016-12-15

26

Scheduling Order

2016-12-20

29

Order amending Scheduling Order dated December 20, 2016

2017-02-13

32

Scheduling Order amending Scheduling Order dated December 20, 2016

2017-02-16

38

Direction scheduling case management conference on March 9, 2017

2017-03-07

39

Order amending the Scheduling Order

2017-03-07

43

Direction refusing the request to adjourn the date for a motion hearing

2017-03-09

55

Direction scheduling CMC of March 20, 2017

2017-03-20

57

Confidentiality Order

2017-03-20

62

Reasons for Order and Order dismissing a motion challenging the Commissioner's claims of public interest privilege

2017-04-24

72

Direction summaries motion

2017-05-08

77

Direction scheduling summaries motion hearing on June 7, 2017

2017-05-11

91

Direction adjourning summaries motion hearing of June 7, 2017

2017-06-02

95

Direction scheduling motion hearing challenging the adequacy and accuracy of summaries on June 26, 2017

2017-06-16

110

Reasons for Order and Order dismissing a motion challenging adequacy and accuracy of summaries

2017-07-04

116

Order amending the Scheduling Order

2017-07-21

135

Order and Reasons for Order granting in part Respondent's motion to compel answers to questions refused on discovery

2017-10-26

146

Direction re: disclosure obligations further to CMC of November 23, 2017

2017-11-24

158

Order and Reasons for Order granting in part Respondent's motion to conduct examination for discovery and to amend the Scheduling Order

2017-12-06

163

Order to further amend the Scheduling Order for filing any motion arising from the further examination for discovery of the Commissioner's representative

2017-12-18

172

Direction re: filing of confidential documents

2018-01-24

181

Direction for filing of documents at public hearing

2018-01-29

183

Order suspending the Scheduling Order and adjourning the hearing

2018-01-29

193

Order amending the hearing dates

2018-02-15

195

Direction re: deadline to March 2, 2018 for scheduling proposal

18-02-15

207

Direction re: draft Scheduling Order

2018-03-09

210

Order amending the Scheduling Order

2018-03-21

218

Direction scheduling Respondent's motion on April 30, 2018

2018-04-12

221

Direction cancelling the motion hearing of April 30, 2018

2018-04-16

223

Order allowing the filing of an amended response

2018-04-18

308

Direction re: Chess-Clock

2018-09-10

309

Direction re: steps further to CMC of September 7, 2018

2018-09-10

320

Order granting the motion of the Commissioner of Competition to file an additional witness statement

2018-09-12

324

Direction scheduling Respondent's motion hearing on September 24, 2018

2018-09-14

351

Order relating to the motion by Vancouver Airport Authority objecting to the admissibility of certain proposed evidence

2018-09-28

369

Direction regarding final submissions

2018-11-05

417

Decision Summary

2019-10-17

429

Reasons for Order and Order

2019-10-17

 

Motion(s) document(s)

 

#

Title

Date

35

Notice of motion of the Respondent challenging a claim of privilege

2017-02-28

53

Motion record

2017-03-17

66

Notice of motion challenging adequacy and accuracy of summaries

2017-05-02

75

Notice of motion on behalf of the Respondent requiring the Applicant to produce complete, adequate and accurate summaries

2017-05-11

81

Motion record of the Respondent

2017-05-12

101

Supplementary motion record re: motion challenging adequacy and accuracy of summaries

2017-06-22

122

Respondent's motion record to compel answers to questions refused on discovery

2017-10-02

157

Notice of motion of VAA

2017-12-01

160

Public version of motion record filed November 30, 2017

2017-12-08

216

Motion record of VAA (Volume 1 of 2)

2018-04-09

217

Motion record of VAA (Volume 2 of 2)

2018-04-09

312

Motion record of the Respondent

2018-09-10

326

Motion record in Response of the Commissioner

2018-09-17

 

 You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.