Case Details

Decision Information

Toronto Real Estate Board - CT-2011-003

Collection	Case Details
Date Filed	2011-05-27
Panel Members	Crampton C.J.; Gascon J.; Dr. Wiktor Askanas; Simpson J.; Mr. Lanctôt; Scott J.
File Number	CT-2011-003
Status	Decided
Type of Application	Abuse of Dominant Position
Section(s) of the Competition Act	s. 79
Hearing Date	2012-09-10 to 2012-09-14 2012-09-18 to 2012-09-19 2012-09-24 to 2012-09-25 2012-09-27 to 2012-09-28 2012-10-02 to 2012-10-03 2012-10-09 to 2012-10-10 2012-10-17 to 2012-10-18 (Initial hearing) 2015-09-21 to 2015-09-24 2015-10-05 to 2015-10-07 2015-11-02 (Redetermination hearing)
Date Completed	2016-04-27

Decision Content

NOTE: Some of the documents on this web page have been provided by external sources and have been inserted, as received, in the language and format of record.
Questions or comments may be sent by e-mail to: tribunal@ct-tc.gc.ca

CT-2011-003 ( Toronto Real Estate Board )

Proceeding 1 Commissioner of Competition v Toronto Real Estate Board
Section(s):	79 - Abuse of dominant position
Filed on:	2011-05-27
Status:	Decided - 2016-04-27

Applicant(s):

Commissioner of Competition

Respondent(s):

Toronto Real Estate Board

Intervenor(s):

Realtysellers Real Estate Inc.

Canadian Real Estate Association

Hearing Date:

2012-09-10 to 2012-09-14

2012-09-18 to 2012-09-19

2012-09-24 to 2012-09-25

2012-09-27 to 2012-09-28

2012-10-02 to 2012-10-03

2012-10-09 to 2012-10-10

2012-10-17 to 2012-10-18 (Initial hearing)

2015-09-21 to 2015-09-24

2015-10-05 to 2015-10-07

2015-11-02 (Redetermination hearing)

Hearing Location:

Toronto

Panel Members:

Crampton C.J.

Gascon J.

Dr. Wiktor Askanas

Simpson J.

Scott J.

Mr. Lanctôt

Case Documents

Pleading(s)

Pleading(s)
#	Title	Date
1	Notice of Application	2011-05-27
10	Amended notice of application	2011-07-07
13	Response	2011-08-19
18	Affidavit of Gary Simonsen	2011-08-31
22	Affidavit of Lawrence Mark Dale	2011-09-01
24	Reply	2011-09-01
31	Affidavit of Donald John Richardson	2011-09-14
33	Response of the Toronto Real Estate Board to the request of the Canadian Real Estate Association for leave to intervene	2011-09-14
43	Response of the Toronto Real Estate Board to the request of Realtysellers Real Estate Inc. for leave to intervene	2011-09-15
46	Reply of the Canadian Real Estate Association to the Commissioner's response to its request for leave to intervene	2011-09-21
47	Supplementary affidavit of Gary Simonsen	2011-09-21
48	Reply brief of authorities of the Canadian Real Estate Association	2011-09-21
124	Affidavit of Nadia Brault	2012-02-27
175	Witness statement of Gary Simonsen	2012-08-03
180	Witness statement of Donald Richardson	2012-07-27
182	Witness statement of William McMullin	2012-06-18
184	Witness statement of Mark Enchin	2012-06-19
186	Witness statement of John Pasalis	2012-06-20
187	Witness statement of Urmi Desai	2012-06-20
188	Witness statement of Scott Nagel	2012-06-20
189	Witness statement of Sam Prochazka	2012-06-22
190	Witness statement of Shayan Hamidi	2012-06-22
191	Witness statement of Tarik Gidamy	2012-06-22
192	Witness statement of Joel Silver	2012-06-22
193	Reply witness statement of Mark Enchin	2012-08-17
197	Witness statement of Timoleon Syrianos	2012-07-27
199	Witness statement of Pamela Prescott	2012-07-27
200	Witness statement of Evan Sage	2012-07-27
201	Witness statement of Tung-Chee Chan	2012-07-27
232	Closing argument of the Canadian Real Estate Association	2012-10-18
235	Closing argument of the Commissioner of Competition	2012-12-03
236	Closing argument of the Toronto Real Estate Board	2012-12-04
288	Witness statement of John Pasalis	2015-02-02
289	Witness statement of Mark Enchin	2015-10-06
291	Witness statement of Sam Prochazka	2015-02-03
293	Witness statement of Scott Nagel	2015-02-05
295	Witness statement of Tarik Gidamy	2015-01-30
297	Witness statement of Bill McMullin	2015-02-05
308	Witness statement of Pamela Prescott	2015-09-24
306	Witness statement of Donald Richardson	2015-10-05
310	Witness statement of Evan Sage	2015-10-06
314	Witness statement of Tung-Chee Chan Tradeworld Realty Inc.	2015-10-06
312	Witness statement of Timoleon Syrianos Ultimate Realty Inc.	2015-11-06
315	Witness statement of Gary Simonsen	2015-06-02
324	Witness statement of Bill McMullin	2015-07-31
357	Closing argument of the Canadian Real Estate Association	2015-11-12
358	Closing argument of the Commissioner of Competition	2015-11-12
359	Closing argument of the Toronto Real Estate Board	2015-11-12
394	Remedy submissions of the Canadian Real Estate Association	2016-05-25
395	Remedy submissions of the Commissioner of Competition	2016-05-25
396	Remedy submissions of the Toronto Real Estate Board	2016-05-25
398	Reply remedy submissions of the Canadian Real Estate Association	2016-05-31
399	Reply remedy submissions of the Commissioner of Competition	2016-05-31
400	Reply remedy submissions of the Toronto Real Estate Board	2016-05-31

Pleading(s)
Motion(s) and Related Document(s)

Other(s)
#	Title	Date
17	Request for leave to intervene of the Canadian Real Estate Association	2011-08-31
19	Brief of authorities	2011-08-31
21	Request for leave to intervene on behalf of Realtysellers Real Estate Inc.	2011-09-01
36	Brief of authorities of the Commissioner	2011-09-14
30	Notice of motion	2011-09-13
35	Response of the Commissioner of Competition to the motions for leave to intervene filed by the Canadian Real Estate Association and Realtysellers Real Estate Inc.	2011-09-14
106	Notice of motion	2012-02-09
123	Notice of motion	2012-02-27
261	Motion record of the Toronto Real Estate Board to stay or adjourn the October 14, 2014 reconsideration hearing	2014-05-23
262	Memorandum of fact and law of the Toronto Real Estate Board to stay or adjourn the October 14, 2014 reconsideration hearing	2014-05-23
267	Memorandum of fact and law of the Commissioner to stay or adjourn the October 14, 2014 reconsideration hearing	2014-05-30
268	Responding motion record of the Commissioner to stay or adjourn the October 14, 2014 reconsideration hearing	2014-05-30
271	Letter of reply of the Toronto Real Estate Board to the motion to stay or adjourn the October 14, 2014 reconsideration hearing	2014-06-03

Pleading(s)
Other(s)

Other(s)
#	Title	Date
194	Expert report of Dr. Greg Vistnes	2012-06-22
202	Expert report of Jeffrey Church	2012-07-27
177	Expert report of Fredrick Flyer	2012-08-13
221	Expert report of Dr. Greg Vistnes in reply	2012-08-23
214	Notice of constitutional question (NOT FILED - see PDF document)	2012-08-29
333	Expert report of Gregory S. Vistnes, Ph.D	2015-02-06
331	Expert report of Fredrick Flyer	2015-06-02
332	Expert report of Jeffrey Church	2015-06-15
334	Expert report of Gregory S. Vistnes, Ph.D.	2015-08-04

Decision(s)

Decision(s)
#	Title	Date
41	Order relating to matters considered at the conference call of September 15, 2011	2011-09-16
59	Order relating to matters considered at the conference call of October 3, 2011	2011-10-03
63	Order extending the time for Realtysellers to serve and file a reply to the Commissioner's response to its motion to intervene	2011-10-04
77	Reasons and Order regarding motions to intervene by Realtysellers Real Estate Inc. and the Canadian Real Estate Association	2011-11-02
95	Scheduling Order	2012-01-20
104	Revised Scheduling Order	2012-02-07
121	Order on the Respondent's motion for a further and better affidavit of documents from the Commissioner	2012-02-21
145	Order on consent	2012-03-20
218	Confidentiality Order	2012-08-30
238	Reasons For Order and Order	2013-04-15
248	Scheduling Order	2014-04-07
255	Scheduling Order	2014-04-23
256	Order quashing the Order granting Realtysellers Real Estate Inc. leave to intervene	2014-04-23
257	Direction	2014-04-23
274	Reasons for Order and Order regarding a motion to stay or adjourn the reconsideration hearing scheduled to start on October 14, 2014	2014-06-18
283	Order on consent with respect to production of MLS data	2014-11-12
301	Revised Scheduling Order	2015-03-16
319	Order amending the revised Scheduling Order of March 16, 2015	2015-06-18
364	Order regarding exhibit A-122	2015-11-25
385	Reasons for Order and Order	2016-04-27
373	Summary of decision	2016-04-28
409	Order further to the reasons issued on April 27, 2016	2016-06-03

You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.

Do not display this message anymore