Case Details

Decision Information

B-Filer Inc. - CT-2005-006

Collection Case Details
Date Filed 2005-06-20
Panel Members Dawson J.; Dr. Csorgo; L.R. Bolton
File Number CT-2005-006
Status Decided
Type of Application Interim Order (Refusal to Deal)
Leave to Make Application under Sections 75, 76, 77 or 79
Refusal to Deal
Section(s) of the Competition Act s. 75; s. 103.1; ss. 104 (75)
Hearing Date 2005-11-12
Date Completed 2006-12-20

Decision Content

NOTE: Some of the documents on this web page have been provided by external sources and have been inserted, as received, in the language and format of record.
Questions or comments may be sent by e-mail to: tribunal@ct-tc.gc.ca

 

CT-2005-006 ( B-Filer Inc. )

 

Proceeding 1

B-Filer Inc., B-Filer Inc. doing business as Gpay Guaranteedpayment and Npay Inc. v. The Bank of Nova Scotia

Section(s):

103.1 - Leave to make application under section 75, 76 or 77

Filed on:

2005-06-20

Status:

Decided - 2005-11-04

 

Applicant(s):

B-Filer Inc.

B-Filer Inc. doing business as Gpay Guaranteedpayment and Npay Inc.

Respondent(s):

The Bank of Nova Scotia

 

Panel Members

Simpson J.

 

Case Documents

 

Pleading(s)

 

#

Title

Date

1a

Notice of Application for leave pursuant to section 103.1 of the Competition Act

2005-06-20

1b

Affidavit of Raymond F. Grace affirmed June 15, 2005

2005-06-20

2

Notice of Application pursuant to sections 75 and 77 of the Competition Act

2005-06-20

4

Letter of R.J. Taylor dated June 23, 2005 confirming that this matter is not or has not been the object of an inquiry by the Commissioner of Competition

2005-06-23

5

Notice from the Tribunal pursuant to section 103.1(5) of the Competition Act

2005-06-24

7a

Affidavit of Robert Rosatelli sworn July 12, 2005 in response to application for leave

2005-07-13

7b

Affidavit of David Metcalfe

2005-07-13

7c

Representations of The Bank of Nova Scotia in response to application for leave pursuant to section 103.1 of the Competition Act

2005-07-13

14

Reply to application for leave

2005-09-06

15

Second affidavit of Raymond F. Grace affirmed September 1, 2005 in support of reply

2005-09-06

16

Affidavit of Joseph Iuso affirmed August 29, 2005 in support of reply

2005-09-06

23

Responding affidavit of Robert Rosatelli sworn September 21, 2005

2005-09-21

 

Motion(s) and Related Document(s)

 

#

Title

Date

27

Notice of motion for summary disposition

2005-09-30

 

Decision(s)

 

 

Proceeding 2

B-Filer Inc., B-Filer Inc. doing business as GPay GuaranteedPayment and NPay Inc. v. The Bank of Nova Scotia

Section(s):

104 (75) - Interim Order (Refusal to Deal)

Filed on:

2005-06-20

Status:

Decided - 2005-12-14

 

Applicant(s):

B-Filer Inc.

B-Filer Inc. doing business as GPay GuaranteedPayment and NPay Inc.

Respondent(s):

The Bank of Nova Scotia

 

Panel Members

Simpson J.

 

Case Documents

 

Pleading(s)

 

#

Title

Date

3

Notice of Application for interim Order pursuant to section 104 of the Competition Act

2005-06-20

50

Affidavit of Christopher Mathers sworn November 23, 2005 (re: 104 Application)

2005-11-28

51

Affidavit of Stanley Sadinsky sworn November 22, 2005 (re: 104 Application)

2005-11-28

52

Affidavit of Alex Todd sworn November 25, 2005 (re: 104 Application)

2005-11-28

53

Affidavit of Colin Cook sworn November 23, 2005 (re: 104 Application)

2005-11-28

54

Affidavit of David Stafford sworn November 24, 2005 (re: 104 Application)

2005-11-28

55

Affidavit of Robert Rosatelli sworn November 25, 2005 (re: 104 Application)

2005-11-28

56

Affidavit of Douglas Monteath sworn November 25, 2005 (re: 104 Application)

2005-11-28

57

Affidavit of Ryan Woodrow sworn November 24, 2005 (re: 104 Application)

2005-11-28

68

Affidavit (third) of Patrick Healey affirmed December 2, 2005 (re: 104 Application)

2005-12-05

69

Affidavit of Aidan Hollis affirmed December 2, 2005 (re: 104 Application)

2005-12-05

70

Affidavit (third) of Raymond F. Grace sworn December 5, 2005 (re: 104 Application)

2005-12-05

 

Decision(s)

 

 

Proceeding 3

B-Filer Inc., B-Filer Inc. doing business as GPay GuaranteedPayment and NPay Inc. v. The Bank of Nova Scotia

Section(s):

75 - Refusal to deal

Filed on:

2005-11-04

Status:

Decided - 2006-12-20

 

Applicant(s):

B-Filer Inc.

B-Filer Inc. doing business as GPay GuaranteedPayment and NPay Inc.

Respondent(s):

The Bank of Nova-Scotia

 

Hearing Date:

2006-08-28

Hearing Location:

Ottawa

Panel Members

Dawson J.

Dr. Csorgo

Mr. Bolton

 

 

Case Documents

 

Pleading(s)

 

 

Motion(s) and Related Document(s)

 

 

Decision(s)

 

#

Title

Date

85

Order setting the date of the hearing

2006-01-13

92

Amended hearing Order

2006-02-17

98

Reasons and Order allowing B-Filer’s motion to amend its notice of application and statement of grounds and material of facts

2006-05-24

104

Scheduling Order following a case management teleconference held June 15,2006

2006-06-16

115

Confidentiality Order - on consent of the parties

2006-08-01

0128

Order relating to matters considered at the hearing management conference of August 18, 2006

2006-08-21

148

Order regarding Applicant's motion to declare the affidavit of Stanley Sadinsky inadmissible

2006-09-22

149

Order re Respondent's motion to amend its response to the amended notice of application

2006-09-26

159

Public version of confidential Reasons for Order

2006-12-20

160

Direction with respect to cost

2007-01-22

165

Direction granting till February 28, 2007 for the parties to reach an agreement with respect to cost

2007-02-21

168

Order dismissing the application and setting out a schedule for the filing of written submissions on costs

2007-03-23

188

Preliminary Reasons for Order and Order regarding costs

2007-08-24

196

Final Order as to costs

2007-11-15

 

Other(s)

 

#

Title

Date

166

Email of L. Constantine, counsel for the Bank of Nova Scotia advising the Tribunal that the parties have been unable to reach an agreement on the issues of costs

2007-02-28

170

Notice of change of solicitor

2007-03-29

190

Further costs submissions of the Respondent

2007-09-07

192

Applicants' responding costs submissions

2007-09-21

193

Respondent's reply costs submissions

2007-10-01

199

Expert affidavit of Dr. Lawrence P. Schwartz

2008-01-07

 

 You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.