Case Details

Decision Information

United Grain (2002) - CT-2002-001

Collection	Case Details
Date Filed	2002-01-02
File Number	CT-2002-001
Status	Decided
Type of Application	Interim Order (Mergers) Mergers
Section(s) of the Competition Act	s. 92; ss.104 (92)
Hearing Date	N/A
Date Completed	2002-10-17

Decision Content

NOTE: Some of the documents on this web page have been provided by external sources and have been inserted, as received, in the language and format of record.
Questions or comments may be sent by e-mail to: tribunal@ct-tc.gc.ca

CT-2002-001 ( United Grain (2002) )

Proceeding 1 The Commissioner of Competition v United Grain Growers Limited
Section(s):	92 – Merger 104 (92) Interim Order (Mergers)
Filed on:	2002-01-02
Status:	Decided - 2002-10-17

Applicant(s):	The Commissioner of Competition
Respondent(s):	United Grain Growers Limited
Intervenor(s):	Canadian Wheat Board

Case Documents

Pleading(s)

Pleading(s)
#	Title	Date
1a	Notice of Application	2002-01-02
1d	Statement of grounds and material facts	2002-01-02
2a	Notice of Application (section 104)	2002-01-02
2b	Affidavit of David Ouellet dated December 19, 2001	2004-01-02

2c	Memorandum of argument	2002-01-02
2e	Draft interim consent Order	2002-01-02
7	Response	2002-02-06
12	Reply	2002-02-25
105a	Consent Agreement	2002-10-17

Decision(s)

Decision(s)
#	Title	Date
5	Interim consent Order	2002-01-14
13	Order extending the time for filing the affidavits of documents	2002-02-28
29	Interim confidentiality (protective) Order	2002-05-27
31	Reasons and Order granting request for leave to intervene	2002-05-29
32	Reasons and Order denying request for leave to intervene	2002-05-29
33	Reasons and Order denying request for leave to intervene	2002-05-29
34	Scheduling Order	2002-05-29
48	Reasons and Order regarding confidentiality, scheduling and retainer of Commissioner's expert witness	2002-07-10
58	Order amending Scheduling Order	2002-08-12
68	Order amending the amended Scheduling Order dated August 12, 2002	2002-09-04
71b	Findings and determinations of the Competition Tribunal pursuant to section 92 of the Competition Act	2002-09-06
74	Findings and determinations of the Competition Tribunal pursuant to section 92 of the Competition Act	2002-09-10
84	Reasons and Order regarding issues considered at pre-hearing conference on August 9, 2002	2002-09-27
85b	Reasons and Order regarding disclosure of will-say statements	2002-10-02
97	Reasons and Order regarding disclosure of will-say statements upon Commissioner's further application	2002-10-07
104b	Reasons and Order regarding Commissioner's refusals	2002-10-17

Proceeding 2 The Commissioner of Competition v United Grain Growers
Section(s):	105 (92) - Registered consent agreement (Mergers)
Filed on:	2006-08-30
Status:	Decided

Applicant(s):	The Commissioner of Competition
Respondent(s):	United Grain Growers Limited

Pleading(s)
Case Documents

Pleading(s)
Pleading(s)

Other(s)
#	Title	Date
105a	Registered Consent Agreement	2002-10-17

Pleading(s)
Motion(s) and Related Document(s)

Other(s)
#	Title	Date
190	Notice of motion on behalf of Commissioner	2006-08-30
191a	Commissioner of Competition's memorandum of argument motion for show cause hearing and relief	2006-08-30
192a	Affidavit of Terence Stechysin	2006-08-30
193a	Notice of motion on behalf of Respondent for Directions/Orders	2006-08-30

Decision(s)

Decision(s)
#	Title	Date
204a	Reasons and Order delivered orally on the motion of United Grain Growers Ltd for an interpretation of the consent agreement Order delivered orally dismissing the Commissioner's motion for a show cause hearing (public version)	2006-09-07
213	Order on motion by Agricore United for an interpretation of the consent agreement	2006-09-26
214a	Reasons for Order of September 26, 2006 on motion by Agricore United for an interpretation of the consent agreement (public version)	2006-09-27

Proceeding 3 United Grain Growers Limited v The Commissioner of Competition
Section(s):	106 (92) - Rescission or variation of consent agreement or order (Mergers)
Filed on:	2005-08-12
Status:	Withdrawn 2006-05-11

Applicant(s):	United Grain Growers Limited
Respondent(s):	The Commissioner of Competition
Intervenor(s):	Canadian Wheat Board Mission Terminal Inc.

Case Documents

Pleading(s)

Pleading(s)
#	Title	Date
113a	Notice of Application (section 106)	2005-08-12
113c	Statement of grounds and material facts regarding the section 106 application - public version	2005-08-22
125b	Affidavit of Ward Weisensel affirmed on September 7, 2005 supporting the request for leave to intervene by the Canadian Wheat Board	2005-09-07
135b	Affidavit of Bruce Hayles sworn on September 26, 2005	2005-09-26
132f	Affidavit in reply of Stanley Murdock Mackay sworn September 19, 2005 (public version)	2005-10-24
146b	Reply of United Grain Growers Limited - public version	2006-01-20
141b	Response of the Commissioner of Competition - public version	2006-01-23
189	Notice of withdrawal of United Grain Growers Limited with respect to the application under s. 106 of the Competition Act	2006-05-11

Pleading(s)
Motion(s) and Related Document(s)

Other(s)
#	Title	Date
112f	Notice of motion for interim relief	2005-08-22
112g	Memorandum of argument concerning motion for interim relief	2005-08-22
112h	Affidavit of Stanley Murdoch Mackay sworn August 11, 2005 regarding the motion for interim relief	2005-08-22
132e	Reply regarding the motion for interim relief (public version)	2005-10-20
128d	Memorandum of argument in response concerning the motion for interim relief - public version	2005-10-24
128e	Affidavit in response concerning motion for interim relief of David Ouellet sworn on September 9, 2005 - public version	2005-10-24

Pleading(s)
Other(s)

Other(s)
#	Title	Date
112i	Statement of grounds and material facts - public version	2005-08-22
125a	Request for leave to intervene by the Canadian Wheat Board	2005-09-07
126	Response to request for leave to intervene	2005-09-09
127	Response to request for leave to intervene	2005-09-12
129	Reply to request for leave to intervene	2005-09-12
135a	Request for leave to intervene of Mission Terminal Inc.	2005-09-26
139	Response to request for leave to intervene by Mission Terminal Inc.	2005-10-11
159b	Expert affidavit of Alan Martyszenko sworn January 17, 2006 (expert report dated December 23, 2005)	2006-02-24
159d	Expert rebuttal affidavit of Alan Martyszenko sworn February 27, 2006 (expert report dated February 24, 2006)	2006-02-24
160b	Expert affidavit of Roger Ware sworn January 11, 2006 (expert report dated December 23, 2005)	2006-02-24
160d	Expert rebuttal affidavit of Roger Ware sworn February 24, 2006	2006-02-24
162b	Expert affidavit of Dr. Ralph Winter sworn January 27, 2006	2006-02-27

Decision(s)

Decision(s)
#	Title	Date
116	Direction to counsel concerning October 3, 2005 hearing of motion for interim relief at 10 a.m. in Ottawa	2005-08-22
123	Direction regarding the proper procedural track for the section 106 application	2005-09-02
124	Direction concerning the Canadian Wheat Board intervenor status	2005-09-02
130	Direction concerning potential intervention of the CWB	2005-09-12
140	Consent Scheduling Order in section 106 application	2005-10-14
142	Reasons and Order granting request for leave to intervene to the Canadian Wheat Board	2005-11-04
143	Reasons and Order granting request for leave to intervene to Mission Terminal Inc.	2005-11-04
150	Order amending Scheduling Order dated October 14, 2005	2005-12-08
158	Interim confidentiality Order - on consent of all parties and intervenors	2006-02-16
167	Order relating to matters considered at the case management conference of March 17, 2006	2006-03-20
184	Order dismissing Commissioner’s motion for summary disposition	2006-04-21
187	Reasons and Order regarding UGG's motion to adjourn its application and, in the alternative, for leave to discontinue without costs	2006-05-10
188	Reasons for Order dismissing Commissioner's motion for summary disposition	2006-05-10

You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.

Do not display this message anymore

Case Details

Decision Information

United Grain (2002) - CT-2002-001

Decision Content

Case Documents

Pleading(s)

Decision(s)

Case Documents

Pleading(s)

Motion(s) and Related Document(s)

Decision(s)

Case Documents

Pleading(s)

Motion(s) and Related Document(s)

Other(s)

Decision(s)