Case Details

Decision Information

Decision Content

NOTE: Some of the documents on this web page have been provided by external sources and have been inserted, as received, in the language and format of record.
Questions or comments may be sent by e-mail to:
tribunal@ct-tc.gc.ca

 

 

Proceeding # 1

Commissioner of Competition v Secure Energy Services Inc. and Tervita Corporation

Section(s):

s. 104 – Interim Order (Mergers)

Filed on:

2021-06-30

Status:

Decided 2021-08-16

 

Applicant(s):

Commissioner of Competition

Respondent(s):

Secure Energy Services Inc.

Tervita Corporation

 

Hearing Date:

2021-08-04

Hearing Location:

Video conference

Panel Members:

Chief Justice P. Crampton

 

Case Documents

 

Pleading(s)

 

 

Decision(s)

 

 

 

 

Other(s)

 

 

 

Proceeding # 2

Commissioner of Competition v Secure Energy Services Inc.

Section(s):

s. 92 – Mergers

Filed on:

2021-06-30

Status:

Ongoing

 

Applicant(s):

Commissioner of Competition

Respondent(s):

Secure Energy Services Inc.

 

Hearing Date:

May 9 to 12, 2022

May 16 to 19, 2022

May 24 to 27, 2022

May 30 to June 2, 2022

Hearing Location:

Ottawa via videoconference

Panel Members:

Chief J. Crampton, J. Gascon and Dr. Ted Horbulyk

 

Case Documents

 

Pleading(s)

 

#

Title

Date

2

Notice of Application (s. 92)

2021-06-29

55

Response from Secure Energy Services Ins. (s. 92)

2021-09-15

56

Reply from the Commissioner (s. 92)

2021-09-29

74

amended Notice of Application (s. 92)

2021-08-20

115

Amended Notice of Application (s.92)

2022-03-11

119

Amended Response (pursuant to amended s.92 Application)

2022-03-28

279

Agreed Statement of Facts

2022-05-03

321

Written Closing Submissions of the Respondent

2022-06-14

324

Written Closing Submissions of the Applicant

2022-06-14

328

Oral Compendium of the Respondent

2022-06-16

333

Submissions on Costs from the Commissioner of Competition

2023-02-10

334

Book of authorities of the Commissioner of Competition in support of Submissions on Costs

2023-02-10

336

Submissions on Costs from Secure Energy Services Inc.

2023-02-10

339

Reply Cost Submissions of the Respondent

2023-02-14

341

Letter from the Commissioner of Competition in Response to the Reply Cost Submissions of Secure Energy Services Inc.

2023-02-15

 

 

Motion document(s)

 

#

Title

Date

64

Motion to compel production of third party documents

2021-11-08

75

Motion record of the Commissioner (refusals motion)

2022-01-21

77

Memorandum of fact and law of the Commissioner of Competition (refusals motion)

2022-01-21

79

Motion record of Secure Energy Services Inc. (refusals motion)

2022-01-21

85

Responding motion record of the Commissioner (Refusals motion)

2022-01-26

88

Responding Memorandum of fact and law of the Commissioner (Refusals motion)

2022-01-26

89

Book of authorities of the Commissioner (Refusals motion)

2022-01-26

92

Book of authorities of Secure Energy Services Inc. (refusals motion)

2022-01-27

93

Responding motion record of Secure Energy Services Inc. (Refusals motion)

2022-01-27

 

Decision(s)

 

#

Title

Date

26

Confidentiality Order

2021-07-13

59

Scheduling Order

2021-10-12

62

Order amending the scheduling order

2021-11-02

65

Direction re: Further filings to Respondent's motion to compel production of third party documents

2021-11-10

67

Direction re: Filing hard copies of authorities further to the direction issued November 10, 2021, regarding the Respondent's motion

2021-11-12

68

Direction re: Cancelling the motion hearing of November 17, 2021

2021-11-12

81

Direction re: Hearing of Refusals motions and the filing of the Responses

2022-01-25

96

Reasons for Order and Order regarding the Commissioner's Motion to compel answers on discovery

2022-02-09

100

Reasons for Order and Order regarding the Respondent's Motion to compel answers to refusal on discovery

2022-02-15

102

Direction regarding the Agreed Book of Documents

2022-02-16

108

Direction regarding filing of documents

2022-02-28

136

Direction re Chess Clock and Sitting Times

2022-04-20

138

Direction re Witness Protocol

2022-04-22

158

Direction re Filing of paper copies

2022-04-27

280

Direction re Exclusion of Witnesses

2022-05-03

314

Direction re Extension Request

2022-06-09

330

Direction re Submissions on Costs

2023-01-25

342

Direction re Issuance of Confidential Reasons

2023-03-03

344

Decision Summary

2023-03-03

349

Order and Reasons for Order (Public)

2023-03-23

 

 

Other(s)

 

 

 You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.