Case Details

Decision Information

Rogers-Shaw - CT-2022-002

Collection	Case Details
Date Filed	2022-05-09
File Number	CT-2022-002
Status	Ongoing
Type of Application	Interim Order (Mergers) Mergers
Section(s) of the Competition Act	ss.104 (92); s. 92
Hearing Date	N/A

Decision Content

NOTE: Some of the documents on this web page have been provided by external sources and have been inserted, as received, in the language and format of record.
Questions or comments may be sent by e-mail to: tribunal@ct-tc.gc.ca

CT-2022-002 (Rogers-Shaw)

Proceeding 1 Commissioner of Competition v Rogers Communications Inc. and Shaw Communications Inc.
Section(s):	ss. 104 (92) – Interim Order (Mergers)
Filed on:	2022-05-09
Status:	Decided

Applicant(s):

Commissioner of Competition

Respondent(s):

Rogers Communications Inc.

Shaw Communications Inc.

Hearing Date:	n/a
Hearing Location:	n/a
Panel Members:	Justice Andrew D. Little

Case Documents

Pleading(s)

Pleading(s)
#	Title	Date
10	Notice of Application pursuant to s. 104 Vol. 1 - Public	2022-05-09
11	Notice of Application pursuant to s. 104 Vol. 2 - Public	2022-05-09
12	Notice of Application pursuant to s. 104 Vol. 3 - Public	2022-05-09
13	Notice of Application pursuant to s. 104 Vol. 4 - Public	2022-05-09
14	Notice of Application pursuant to s. 104 Vol. 5 - Public	2022-05-09
15	Notice of Application pursuant to s. 104 Vol. 6 - Public	2022-05-09
16	Notice of Application pursuant to s. 104 Vol. 7 – Public	2022-05-09
43	Registered Consent Agreement (s. 104)	2022-05-30

Decision(s)

Decision(s)
#	Title	Date
27	Scheduling Order (s.104)	2022-05-18
30	Confidentiality Order	2022-05-19

Proceeding 2 Commissioner of Competition v Rogers Communications Inc. and Shaw Communications Inc.; and Videotron Ltd, Intervenor.
Section(s):	s. 92 – Mergers
Filed on:	2022-05-09
Status:	Decided: 2023-01-01

Applicant(s):

Commissioner of Competition

Respondent(s):

Rogers Communications Inc.

Shaw Communications Inc.

Intervenor(s):

Videotron Ltd.

Hearing Dates:

November 7 to 10, 2022
November 14 to 18, 2022
November 21 to 25, 2022
November 28 to December 1, 2022

December 13 and 14, 2022

Hearing Location:

Ottawa via Videoconference

Panel Members:

Chief Justice Paul Crampton

Case Documents

Pleading(s)

Pleading(s)
#	Title	Date
2	Notice of Application pursuant to s. 92 – Public	2022-05-09
44	Response of Rogers Communications Inc.	2022-06-03
45	Response of Shaw Communications Inc.	2022-06-03
53	Commissioner's reply to Rogers Response	2022-06-16
54	Commissioner's reply to Shaw’s Response	2022-06-16
146	Affidavit of Daniel Stern, Telus Corporation	2022-08-03
148	Affidavit of Andy Kaplan-Myrth, TekSavvy	2022-08-03
151	Affidavit of Mark Graham, Bell	2022-08-03
162	Amended Response from Shaw Communications Inc.	2022-08-09
164	Amended Response from Rogers Communications Inc.	2022-08-09
191	Amended Reply to the Response of Rogers Communications Inc. of the Commissioner of Competition	2022-08-15
192	Amended Reply to the Response of Shaw Communications Inc. of the Commissioner of Competition	2022-08-15
177	Fresh as Amended Response from Shaw Communications Inc.	2022-08-19
179	Fresh as Amended Response from Rogers Communications Inc.	2022-08-19
194	Fresh as Amended Reply to the Response of Rogers Communications Inc. of the Commissioner of Competition	2022-09-02
195	Fresh as Amended Reply to the Response of Shaw Communications Inc. of the Commissioner of Competition	2022-09-02
322	Affidavit of Andrew Harington	2022-09-28
658	Book of authorities from Shaw - Opening Statement	2022-11-07
774	Commissioner's Final Arguments	2022-12-09
775	Commissioner's Final Arguments (Book of Authorities)	2022-12-09
778	Respondent's Final Arguments	2022-12-09
784	Rogers Compendium	2022-12-13
788	Shaw's Compendium	2022-12-13
791	Videotron's Compendium	2022-12-13
795	Presentation on closing submissions of the Commissioner	2022-12-13
796	Book of Authorities of the Commissioner on Final Submissions	2022-12-13
817	Commissioner’s Cost Submissions	2022-12-29
819	Rogers, Shaw and Videotron’s Cost Submissions	2022-12-30
854	Affidavit evidence of Ashley McKnight regarding Rogers' disbursements	2023-07-18
855	Affidavit evidence of Debra Bilous regarding Shaw's disbursements	2023-07-20
856	Affidavit evidence of Elizabeth Fimio regarding Videotron's disbursements	2023-07-20
861	Commissioner's Supplementary Submission on Costs	2023-08-04
862	Book of Authorities in support of the Commissioner's Supplementary Submission on Costs	2023-08-04

Pleading(s)
Motion(s) document(s)

Motion(s) document(s)
#	Title	Date
62	Motion to Intervene by Videotron Ltd.	2022-07-08
69	Request for Leave to Intervene by John P. Roman	2022-07-21
70	Response of the Commissioner of Competition to the Request for Leave to Intervene of John P. Roman	2022-07-21
71	Confidentiality and Privilege Motion by the Respondents	2022-07-21
75	Book of authorities in support of the Commissioner's Response to the motion to intervene of J.P. Roman	2022-07-21
77	Commissioner's Response to Videotron's Motion to Intervene	2022-07-21
78	Book of authorities in support of the Commissioner's Response to the motion to intervene of Videotron	2022-07-25
80	Commissioner's Motion Record requesting an Order varying the Scheduling Order	2022-07-21
93	Responding Motion Record of the Commissioner to the Respondents Motion for Confidentiality and Privilege	2022-07-29
108	Videotron's responding Motion Record to the Commissioner’s Motion to Vary the Scheduling Order	2022-07-29
110	Videotron's Written Reply Submissions on their Request for Leave to Intervene	2022-07-29
113	Shaw's Responding Motion Record to the Commissioner's Motion to Vary the Scheduling Order	2022-07-29
116	Commissioner's Motion to Vary the Confidentiality Order	2022-07-29
122	Commissioner's Motion for a further and better affidavit of Documents from Rogers Communications Inc.	2022-07-29
130	Affidavit of Documents of Marisa Wyse, Rogers Communications Inc.	2022-07-29
136	Commissioner's Motion for a further and better affidavit of Documents from Shaw Communications Inc.	2022-07-29
141	Affidavit of Documents of Dean Shaikh, Shaw Communications Inc.	2022-07-29
201	Commisioner's Motion on Rogers' Discovery Refusals	2022-09-08
202	Commissioner's Book of Authorities - Motion on Rogers' Discovery Refusals	2022-09-08
205	Commissioner's Motion on Shaw's Discovery Refusals	2022-09-08
206	Commissioners Book of Authorities - Motion on Shaw's Discovery Refusals	2022-09-08
211	Motion Record of Rogers and Shaw on Refusals	2022-09-12
214	Memorandum of fact and law of Rogers and Shaw on their motion for Refusals	2022-09-12
221	Oral Compendium of the Respondents, Rogers and Shaw (Refusals Motion)	2022-09-12
227	Responding Motion Record of Rogers on the Commissioner's Refusals Motion	2022-09-12
234	Commissioner's Book of Authorities (Respondent's Refusals Motion)	2022-09-12
237	Commissioner's Compendium for Oral Arguments (Refusals Motion)	2022-09-13
239	Revised Commissioner's Responding Motion Record on the Respondent's Refusals Motion	2022-09-12
356	Motion Record of Shaw Communications Inc. re: Confidentiality	2022-10-06
372	Motion record from Telus to quash subpoenas	2022-10-14
381	Notice of Motion to Strike from the Commissioner	2022-10-14
384	Written Representations of the Commissioner of Competition in support of his Motion to Strike	2022-10-17
385	Book of Authorities in Support of the Commissioner's Motion to Strike	2022-10-17
389	Notice of Motion to Strike from the Respondents	2022-10-17
391	Supplementary Affidavit of Telus	2022-10-18
393	Responding Motion Record of the Commissioner on Telus' Motion to Quash Subpoenas	2022-10-18
395	Responding Motion Record of the Commissioner on Bell's Motion to Quash Subpoenas	2022-10-18
399	Shaw's Notice of Cross-Motion to Compel the Commissioner to Produce Documents	2022-10-18
433	Bell's Supplementary Motion Record on the Motion to Quash Subpoena	2022-10-20
434	Shaw's Responding Motion Record on the Commissioner's Motion to Strike	2022-10-20
435	Shaw's Response to Bell and Telus Motions to Quash	2022-10-19
437	Affidavit of Tanya Barbiero on Bell and Telus' Motions to Quash	2022-10-19
440	Responding Motion Record of Rogers on Bell's Motion to Quash Subpoenas	2022-10-19
445	Responding Motion Record of Rogers on Telus' Motion to Quash Subpoenas	2022-10-19
452	Notice of motion for leave to file a witness statement	2022-10-20
457	Commissioner's response to Respondents' motion to strike	2022-10-21
521	Motion Record of the Commissioner in Response to Shaw's Cross-Motion	2022-10-21
522	Book of Authorities of the Commissioner in Response to Shaw's Cross-Motion	2022-10-21
524	Response of the Commissioner to Rogers' Motion for leave to file a Witness Statement	2022-10-21
528	Second Supplementary Affidavit of Dean Stern, Telus	2022-10-24
535	Memorandum of Fact and Law of Telus on the Motion to Quash Subpoenas	2022-10-26
536	Book of Authorities of Telus on the Motion to Quash Subpoenas	2022-10-26
538	Commissioner's Written Representations (Respondents' Motion to Strike) – Public	2022-10-26
539	Commissioner's Book of Authorities (Respondents' Motion to Strike) – Publi	2022-10-26
543	Memorandum of Fact and Law of Rogers on the Motion to Strike – Public	2022-10-26
548	Memorandum of Shaw on the Motion to Strike – Public	2022-10-26
550	Memorandum of Fact and Law of the Commissioner on the Respondents' Motion to Introduce – Public	2022-10-26
552	Bell Motion to Quash Subpoenas - Amended Notice of Motion – Public	2022-10-26
557	Amended Response of the Comissioner on Cross Motions Public	2022-10-27
560	Affidavit of Jessica Fiset in support of amended response to Cross-Motions -Public	2022-10-27
564	Rogers Compendium on CoC's Motion to Strike and Rogers' Motion for leave to file new witness statement – Public	2022-10-27
570	Memorandum of Fact and Law from Rogers in Response to Bell and Telus' Motions to Quash Public	2022-10-27
574	Rogers' Compendium for Oral Argument (Response to Bell and Telus' Motions to Quash) – Public	2022-10-27
578	Notice of Motion from the Commissioner to Strike Reply Evidence (Isreal and Butt) Public	2022-10-27
579	Book of Authorities on Commissioner's Motion to Strike Reply Evidence (Isreal and Butt)	2022-10-27
583	Memorandum of Fact and Law from Shaw in Response to Bell and Telus' Motions to Quash Subpoenas	2022-10-28
587	Factum from Bell on motion to Quash – Public	2022-10-28
588	Book of Authorities from Bell on motion to Quash	2022-10-28

Decision(s)

Decision(s)
#	Title	Date
30	Confidentiality Order	2022-05-19
51	Scheduling Order (s.92)	2022-06-17
57	Amended Scheduling Order	2022-06-24
103	Direction re Scheduling of Certain Motions	2022-08-02
104	Direction re Scheduling of two interlocutory motions	2022-08-02
154	Order re Videotron's Motion for Leave to Intervene	2022-08-04
155	Order re Motion Varying the Scheduling Order	2022-08-04
167	Revised Order Amending the Confidentiality Order On Consent	2022-08-10
172	Order on Consent (Motions regarding Affidavits of Documents)	2022-08-15
174	Reasons for Order and Order Dismissing the Motion for leave to Intervene by J.P. Roman	2022-08-19
184	Direction re Confidentiality Order	2022-08-23
188	Order regarding Refusals Motion Arising from Discovery	2022-08-26
189	Order regarding the admission for filing of fresh as amended responses from the Respondents	2022-08-26
198	Direction re: Upcoming Case Management Conference	2022-09-07
215	Amended Confidentiality Order	2022-09-12
240	Rogers-Shaw - Direction re CMC of September 15, 2022	2022-09-16
246	Amended Direction re Case Management Conference of September 26, 2022	2022-09-22
292	Direction re Hearing Format and Upcoming CMC	2022-09-27
368	Direction re Shaw's motion withdrawal and scheduling CMC	2022-10-12
431	Direction re Filing of motions materials	2022-10-19
448	Direction scheduling CMC of October 21, 2022	2022-10-20
526	Order Amending the Scheduling Order	2022-10-24
584	Direction to counsel re Hearing of Motions and CMC	2022-10-28
589	Reasons for Order and Order on Motions to Compel Answers to Questions Refused on Examinations for Discovery	2022-09-15
593	Direction re Upcoming Case Management Conference	2022-10-31
621	Order Amending the Scheduling Order	2022-11-02
622	Direction re Chess Clock and Sitting Times	2022-11-02
623	Direction re Witness Protocol	2022-11-02
624	Direction re Witness Exclusion	2022-11-02
641	Order re Motion to Strike Portions of Witness Statements Delivered by the Commissioner	2022-11-04
656	Direction re: Agreed Statement of Fact	2022-11-07
683	Public Order concerning Claim of Solicitor-Client Privilege	2022-11-10
706	Order on Motion to Quash, by Telus Communications Inc., Nazim Benhadid and Charlie Casey	2022-11-04
707	Order on Motion to Quash, by BCE Inc., Blaik Kirby and Stephen Howe	2022-11-04
768	Direction re Closing Arguments	2022-12-06
812	Direction re Costs	2022-12-21
826	Summary Decision	2022-12-29
829	Direction re IP addresses	2022-12-29
832	Reasons for Order and Order	2023-01-01
850	Direction to Respondents and Intervenor on disbursements’ supporting evidence	2023-06-22
858	Direction re Commissioner's Additional Submission on Costs	2023-07-28
865	Reasons for Order and Order on Costs	2023-08-28
867	Concurrence on Costs	2023-08-30

Other(s)

Decision(s)
#	Title	Date
49	Commissioner's Demand for Particulars	2022-06-16
50	Rogers' response to the Demand for Particulars	2022-06-16
56	Parties letter confirming intent for mediation	2022-06-23
60	Notice of Intervention by the Attorney General of Alberta	2022-07-04
197	Rogers Communications Inc.'s Demand for Particulars	2022-09-06
217	Commissioner's Response to Rogers' Demand for Particulars	2022-09-12
251	Witness Statement of Stephen Howe (Bell)	2022-09-26
253	Witness Statement of Nazim Benhadid (Telus)	2022-09-20
257	Witness Statement of Christopher Hickey (Distributel)	2022-09-26
259	Witness Statement of Tom Nagel (Comcast)	2022-09-26
263	Witness Statement of Sudeep Verma	2022-09-26
264	Witness Statement of Denis Albert	2022-09-26
269	Witness Statement of Mathew McCarthy	2022-09-26
271	Witness Statement of David Bennett	2022-09-26
273	Witness Statement of Andre Bremault	2022-09-26
275	Witness Statement of Shane Reimer	2022-09-26
277	Witness Statement of Ryan Schumm	2022-09-26
279	Witness Statement of Mark Phaneuf	2022-09-26
281	Witness Statement of Nimesh Chauhan	2022-09-26
288	Expert Report of Nathan H. Miller	2022-09-26
289	Expert Report of Lars Osberg	2022-09-21
290	Expert Report of Katherine Cuff	2022-09-21
319	Expert Report of Mark A. Israel	2022-09-23
325	Witness Statement of Dean Prevost	2022-09-23
328	Witness Statement of Marisa Fabiano	2022-09-28
340	Witness Statement of Jean-François Lescadres	2022-09-28
367	Letter from the Applicant requesting a second mediation	2022-10-12
370	Letter from the Respondents requesting a second mediation	2022-10-12
371	Letter from the intervenor, Videotron, requesting a second mediation	2022-10-12
374	Statement (from Justice Little, Chairperson)	2022-10-14
454	Witness Statement of Alexandre Mercier-Dalphond	2022-10-20
462	Expert Report of Mark E Zmijewski	2022-10-20
464	Rebuttal Expert Report of Nathan H. Miller	2022-10-19
469	Reply Witness Statement of Mathew McCarthy	2022-10-20
472	Witness Statement of Jessica Fiset	2022-10-20
487	Expert Report of David S. Evans	2022-10-20
491	Witness Statement of Evan Fuest	2022-10-20
494	Supplementary Witness Statement of Mohamed Drif	2022-10-20
497	Reply Witness Statement of Jean-Francois Lescadres	2022-10-21
502	Witness statement of Roger Ware	2022-10-21
505	Reply Expert Report of Mark A. Israel	2022-10-21
508	Responding Witness Statement Dean Prevost	2022-10-21
514	Witness Statement of Michael Smart	2022-10-21
604	Commissioner's Opening Statement	2022-10-31
605	Book of authorities of the Commissioner / Opening Statement	2022-10-31
608	Videotron's Opening Statement	2022-10-31
612	Rogers' Opening Statement	2022-10-31
617	Shaw's Opening Statement	2022-11-01
645	Letter from Alberta Attorney General re: Intervention withdrawal	2022-11-04
649	Witness Statement of Sameer Dhamani (Freedom Dealers)	2022-09-26
654	Witness Statement of Stephanie Assad	2022-09-26
667	Witness Statement of Charlie Casey (Telus)	2022-09-26
669	Witness Statement of Blaik Kirby (Bell)	2022-09-26
670	Affidavit of Kenneth Mathieu	2022-10-20
679	Witness Statement of Pierre Karl Péladeau	2022-09-23
680	Witness Statement of Mohamed Drif	2022-09-28
690	Amended Expert Report of Michael A. M. Davies	2022-09-23
693	Amended Reply Expert Report of Michael A. M. Davies	2022-09-23
696	Letter from the Commissioner and Excel Spreadsheet in Response to Questions Posed by the Panel concerning s.96	2022-11-16
705	Shaw Communications Inc. Responses to Questions Posed by the Panel	2022-11-18
712	Reply Witness Statement of Paul McAleese	2022-10-20
715	Witness Statement of Paul McAleese	2022-09-26
718	Witness Statement of Brad Shaw	2022-09-28
720	Witness Statement of Donovan Leigh Annett	2022-10-10
722	Witness Statement of Rod Davies	2022-09-28
729	Amended Witness Statement of Trevor English	2022-09-28
739	Expert Report of Kenneth J. Martin	2022-09-23
742	Witness Statement of Kenneth J. Martin	2022-10-21
748	Expert Report of Dr. William Webb	2022-10-20
751	Reply Expert Report of Dr. William Webb	2022-10-20
754	Amended Expert Report of Paul Alan Johnson	2022-09-28
756	Reply Expert Report of Paul Alan Johnson	2022-10-21
763	Witness Statement of Ron McKenzie	2022-10-21
842	Statement (from Chief Justice Crampton, Presiding Member)	2023-01-18

You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.

Do not display this message anymore

Case Details

Decision Information

Rogers-Shaw - CT-2022-002

Decision Content

Case Documents

Pleading(s)

Decision(s)

Case Documents

Pleading(s)

Motion(s) document(s)

Decision(s)

Other(s)