Case Details

Decision Information

Parrish & Heimbecker, Limited - CT-2019-005

Collection	Case Details
Date Filed	2019-12-19
Panel Members	Gascon J.; Little J.; Ms. Samrout
File Number	CT-2019-005
Status	Decided
Type of Application	Mergers
Section(s) of the Competition Act	s. 92
Hearing Date	January 6, 7, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 19, 20, 21, 25, 27, 2021 February 3 and 4, 2021
Date Completed	2022-10-31

Decision Content

NOTE: Some of the documents on this web page have been provided by external sources and have been inserted, as received, in the language and format of record.
Questions or comments may be sent by e-mail to: tribunal@ct-tc.gc.ca

CT-2019-005 ( Parrish & Heimbecker, Limited )

Proceeding 1 Commissioner of Competition v Parrish & Heimbecker, Limited
Section(s):	92 – Merger
Filed on:	2019-12-19
Status:	Decided 2022-10-31

Applicant(s):	Commissioner of Competition
Respondent(s):	Parrish & Heimbecker, Limited

Panel Members:

J. Gascon

J. Little

Ms. Samrout

Case Documents

Pleading(s)

Pleading(s)
#	Title	Date
2	Notice of Application	2019-12-19
22	Response	2020-02-03
24	Reply of the Commissioner of Competition	2020-02-17
146	Joint book of authorities	2020-12-02
209	Agreed statement of facts	2021-01-04
234	Final submissions of the Applicant	2021-02-01
238	Final submissions of the Respondent	2021-02-05
241	Written submissions of the Commissioner to panel questions	2021-02-16
242	P&H written submissions to Panel questions	2021-02-16
243	Compendium of authorities from P&H to panel questions	2021-02-16
257	Commissioner’s submissions on 1991 MEG's	2021-04-07
259	Respondent's submissions on 1991 MEG's	2021-04-07
260	Submissions on Costs from the Applicant	2021-04-09
264	Submissions on Costs from the Respondent	2021-04-09
265	Respondent’s Book of Authorities (Submissions on Costs)	2021-04-09
269	Amended Submissions on Costs from the Respondent	2021-04-15

Motion(s) document(s)

Pleading(s)
#	Title	Date
129	Motion challenging the admissibility of certain proposed evidence	2020-11-27
130	Memorandum of fact and law	2020-11-27
131	Book of authorities	2020-11-27
151	Motion record in response to Commissioner's motion to strike PUBLIC	2020-12-07
152	Memorandum of fact and law in response to Commissioner's motion to strike	2020-12-07
155	Book of authorities in support of motion to designate witnesses identities confidential	2020-12-07
170	Book of authorities in response on motion to designate identities of witnesses confidential	2020-12-15
185	Memorandum of fact and law in response on motion to designate identities of witnesses confidential	2020-12-15
186	Responding motion record on motion to designate identities of witnesses confidential	2020-12-15
195	Motion record to designate identities of witnesses confidential	2020-12-17
196	Book of authorities in support of motion to designate witnesses identities confidential	2020-12-17
197	Memorandum of fact and law on motion to designate identities of witnesses confidential	2020-12-18

Decision(s)

Decision(s)
#	Title	Date
12	Order regarding the Commissioner's request for an expedited proceeding process	2020-01-13
29	Scheduling Order	2020-03-04
30	Confidentiality Order	2020-03-04
34	Direction re: updated April 15, 2020 COVID-19 Notice	2020-04-15
38	Order amending the Scheduling Order	2020-04-21
44	Direction re: allowing the Commissioner an extension of time to file a public version of expert report	2020-09-01
51	Order amending the amended Scheduling Order	2020-09-08
61	Direction re: extension of time	2020-10-08
63	Order amending the amended Scheduling Order	2020-10-09
69	Order amending the revised schedule for the remaining pre-hearing steps and hearing	2020-10-16
114	Order suspending the revised schedule for the remaining pre-hearing steps and adjourning the hearing	2020-10-30
118	Direction re: proposed new hearing dates	2020-11-04
120	Direction re: Further steps following the CMC of November 5, 2020	2020-11-06
124	Order establishing a further amended schedule for the remaining pre-hearing steps and the hearing	2020-11-13
125	Direction further to case management conference of November 12, 2020	2020-11-13
137	Direction re motion on evidence	2020-12-01
138	Direction re confidential witnesses	2020-12-01
147	Direction re chess clock and sitting times	2020-12-03
148	Direction re Concurrent evidence session (“hot-tubbing”) for expert witnesses	2020-12-03
160	Order on the hearing format	2020-12-09
176	Direction re Counsel submissions	2020-12-15
178	Order on Commissioner's motion relating to the evidence	2020-12-15
180	Direction re motion on P&H reply on efficiencies	2020-12-15
182	Direction re Motion on confidentiality designations	2020-12-15
187	Direction re motion on P&H reply on efficiencies	2020-12-16
189	Direction re Motion on confidentiality designations	2020-12-16
191	Direction re Witness protocol	2020-12-17
202	Order on confidentiality designations	2020-12-29
210	Order on the hearing format for the second part of the hearing	2021-01-05
212	Direction re Concurrent evidence session (“hot-tubbing”) for expert witnesses	2021-01-05
213	Reasons for Order dismissing motion on confidentiality	2021-01-05
221	Order amending the Confidentiality Order of March 4, 2020	2021-01-07
227	Direction re Costs	2021-01-26
229	Direction re final oral argument	2021-01-26
244	Direction re Merger Enforcement Guidelines	2021-03-10
290	Direction Re Release of Confidential Reasons	2022-10-31
291	Decision Summary	2022-10-31
296	Reasons for Order and Order on the Application	2022-10-31

Other(s)

Pleading(s)
#	Title	Date
55	Expert report of Nathan Miller (public version)	2020-09-11
102	Expert report of Margaret Sanderson (Public version)	2020-10-19
205	Expert report of Andrew C. Harrington	2020-10-23
206	Reply expert report of Nathan Miller	2020-10-23

You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.

Do not display this message anymore