Case Details

Decision Information

Decision Content

NOTE: Some of the documents on this web page have been provided by external sources and have been inserted, as received, in the language and format of record.
Questions or comments may be sent by e-mail to:
tribunal@ct-tc.gc.ca

 

CT-2019-005 ( Parrish & Heimbecker, Limited )

 

Proceeding 1

Commissioner of Competition v Parrish & Heimbecker, Limited

Section(s):

92 – Merger

Filed on:

2019-12-19

Status:

Decided 2022-10-31

 

Applicant(s):

Commissioner of Competition

Respondent(s):

Parrish & Heimbecker, Limited

 

Panel Members:

Gascon J.

Little J

Ms. Samrout

 

Case Documents

 

Pleading(s)

 

#

Title

Date

2

Notice of Application

2019-12-19

22

Response

2020-02-03

24

Reply of the Commissioner of Competition

2020-02-17

146

Joint book of authorities

2020-12-02

209

Agreed statement of facts

2021-01-04

234

Final submissions of the Applicant

2021-02-01

238

Final submissions of the Respondent

2021-02-05

241

Written submissions of the Commissioner to panel questions

2021-02-16

242

P&H written submissions to Panel questions

2021-02-16

243

Compendium of authorities from P&H to panel questions

2021-02-16

257

Commissioner’s submissions on 1991 MEG's

2021-04-07

259

Respondent's submissions on 1991 MEG's

2021-04-07

 

Motion(s) document(s)

 

#

Title

Date

129

Motion challenging the admissibility of certain proposed evidence

2020-11-27

130

Memorandum of fact and law

2020-11-27

131

Book of authorities

2020-11-27

151

Motion record in response to Commissioner's motion to strike PUBLIC

2020-12-07

152

Memorandum of fact and law in response to Commissioner's motion to strike

2020-12-07

155

Book of authorities in support of motion to designate witnesses identities confidential

2020-12-07

170

Book of authorities in response on motion to designate identities of witnesses confidential

2020-12-15

185

Memorandum of fact and law in response on motion to designate identities of witnesses confidential

2020-12-15

186

Responding motion record on motion to designate identities of witnesses confidential

2020-12-15

195

Motion record to designate identities of witnesses confidential

2020-12-17

196

Book of authorities in support of motion to designate witnesses identities confidential

2020-12-17

197

Memorandum of fact and law on motion to designate identities of witnesses confidential

2020-12-18

 

 

Decision(s)

 

#

Title

Date

12

Order regarding the Commissioner's request for an expedited proceeding process

2020-01-13

29

Scheduling Order

2020-03-04

30

Confidentiality Order

2020-03-04

34

Direction re: updated April 15, 2020 COVID-19 Notice

2020-04-15

38

Order amending the Scheduling Order

2020-04-21

44

Direction re: allowing the Commissioner an extension of time to file a public version of expert report

2020-09-01

51

Order amending the amended Scheduling Order

2020-09-08

61

Direction re: extension of time

2020-10-08

63

Order amending the amended Scheduling Order

2020-10-09

69

Order amending the revised schedule for the remaining pre-hearing steps and hearing

2020-10-16

114

Order suspending the revised schedule for the remaining pre-hearing steps and adjourning the hearing

2020-10-30

118

Direction re: proposed new hearing dates

2020-11-04

120

Direction re: Further steps following the CMC of November 5, 2020

2020-11-06

124

Order establishing a further amended schedule for the remaining pre-hearing steps and the hearing

2020-11-13

125

Direction further to case management conference of November 12, 2020

2020-11-13

137

Direction re motion on evidence

2020-12-01

138

Direction re confidential witnesses

2020-12-01

147

Direction re chess clock and sitting times

2020-12-03

148

Direction re Concurrent evidence session (“hot-tubbing”) for expert witnesses

2020-12-03

160

Order on the hearing format

2020-12-09

176

Direction re Counsel submissions

2020-12-15

178

Order on Commissioner's motion relating to the evidence

2020-12-15

180

Direction re motion on P&H reply on efficiencies

2020-12-15

182

Direction re Motion on confidentiality designations

2020-12-15

187

Direction re motion on P&H reply on efficiencies

2020-12-16

189

Direction re Motion on confidentiality designations

2020-12-16

191

Direction re Witness protocol

2020-12-17

202

Order on confidentiality designations

2020-12-29

210

Order on the hearing format for the second part of the hearing

2021-01-05

212

Direction re Concurrent evidence session (“hot-tubbing”) for expert witnesses

2021-01-05

213

Reasons for Order dismissing motion on confidentiality

2021-01-05

221

Order amending the Confidentiality Order of March 4, 2020

2021-01-07

227

Direction re Costs

2021-01-26

229

Direction re final oral argument

2021-01-26

244

Direction re Merger Enforcement Guidelines

2021-03-10

290

Direction Re Release of Confidential Reasons

2022-10-31

291

Decision Summary

2022-10-31

296

Reasons for Order and Order on the Application

2022-10-31

 

Other(s)

 

 

 You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.