Case Details

Decision Information

Superior Propane Inc. - CT-1998-002

Collection	Case Details
Date Filed	1998-12-01
Panel Members	Nadon J.; L.P. Schwartz; C. Lloyd
File Number	CT-1998-002
Status	Decided
Type of Application	Interim Order (Mergers) Interim order where no application under section 92 Mergers
Section(s) of the Competition Act	s. 92; s. 100; ss.104 (92)
Hearing Date	September 23, 24, 27-29, 1999; October 04-08, 13-15, 18-21, 25-29, 1999; November 01-03, 23, 25, 29, 30, 1999; December 01-03, 06-09, 13, 14, 1999; January 19, 24, 31, 2000; February 01-04, 07-09, 2000
Date Completed	2002-04-04

Decision Content

NOTE: Some of the documents on this web page have been provided by external sources and have been inserted, as received, in the language and format of record.
Questions or comments may be sent by e-mail to: tribunal@ct-tc.gc.ca

CT-1998-002 ( Superior Propane Inc. )

Proceeding 1 Commissioner of Competition v Superior Propane Inc., ICG Propane Inc. and Petro-Canada
Section(s):	s. 100 - Interim order where no application under section 92
Filed on:	1998-12-01
Status:	Decided: 1999-12-06

Applicant(s):

Commissioner of Competition

Respondent(s):

Superior Propane Inc.

ICG Propane Inc.

Petro-Canada

Hearing Dates:	December 4-6, 1998
Hearing Location:	Ottawa
Panel Members:	Rothstein J.

Case Documents

Pleading(s)

Pleading(s)
#	Title	Date
1a	Notice of Application for an interim Order pursuant to section 100 of the Competition Act	1998-12-01
1b	Affidavit of John Pecman sworn November 30, 1998	1998-12-01
1d	Memorandum of argument	1998-12-01
3e	Affidavit in reply of Geoffrey N. Mackey sworn December 3, 1998	1998-12-04
3f	Affidavit in reply of Peter D. Jones sworn December 3, 1998	1998-12-04
2a	Memorandum of argument in reply (Interim Order) of Petro-Canada Inc. (Document # 1a)	1998-12-06
2b	Affidavit of Andrew Stephens sworn December 3, 1998	1998-12-06
3a	Memorandum of argument in reply (Interim Order) of Superior Propane Inc. (Document # 1a)	1998-12-06

Decision(s)

Decision(s)
#	Title	Date
8	Order regarding use of information subject to privilege	1998-12-04
7	Reasons and Order regarding the introduction of portions of the examination of Andrew Wiswell	1998-12-05
5	Order regarding application for interim Order under section 100 of the Competition Act	1998-12-06
9	Reasons for Order regarding application for interim Order under section 100 of the Competition Act	1998-12-06

Proceeding 2 Commissioner of Competition v Superior Propane Inc., ICG Propane Inc., Petro-Canada and The Chancellor Holdings Corporation
Section(s):	s. 92 – Mergers
Filed on:	1998-12-07
Status:	Decided: 2000-04-04

Applicant(s):

Commissioner of Competition

Respondent(s):

Superior Propane Inc.

ICG Propane Inc.

Petro-Canada

The Chancellor Holdings Corporation

Hearing Dates:

September 23, 24, 27-29, 1999;

October 04-08, 13-15, 18-21, 25-29, 1999;

November 01-03, 23, 25, 29, 30, 1999;

December 01-03, 06-09, 13, 14, 1999;

January 19, 24, 31, 2000;

February 01-04, 07-09, 2000

Hearing Location:

Calgary

Panel Members:

Nadon J.

L.R. Bolton

C. Lloyd

L.P. Schwartz

Case Documents

Pleading(s)

Pleading(s)
#	Title	Date
6	Notice of Application pursuant to section 92 of the Competition Act superseded by document # 20	1998-12-07
20	Notice of Application (amended) under section 92 of the Competition Act supersedes document # 6	1998-12-23
22	Response of Petro-Canada and the Chancellor Holdings Corporation (Document # 20)	1999-01-29
23	Response of Superior Propane Inc. and ICG Propane Inc. (Document # 20) superseded by document # 62	1999-01-29
26	Reply to Superior Propane Inc. and ICG Propane Inc. (Document # 20)	1999-02-12
27	Reply to Petro-Canada and the Chancellor Holdings Corporation (Document # 20)	1999-02-12
62	Response (amended) of Superior Propane Inc. and ICG Propane Inc. (Document # 20) supersedes document # 23	1999-02-12

Other(s)

Decision(s)
#	Title	Date
90a	Expert affidavit of D. McFetridge dated August 18, 1999	1999-08-17
89a	Expert affidavit of C. O'Leary and E. Fergin dated August 17, 1999 expurgated copy	1999-08-18
112	Expert affidavit of R. Schwindt and S. Globerman dated August 16, 1999	1999-09-01
113a	Expert affidavit of Gerrard Mathieson dated August 18, 1999	1999-09-01
114	Expert affidavit of D. Ryan and A. Plourde dated August 16, 1999	1999-09-01
115	Expert affidavit of P. Townley dated August 16, 1999	1999-09-01
116	Expert affidavit of T. Kemp dated August 18, 1999	1999-09-01
117	Expert affidavit of M.D. Whinston dated August 18, 1999	1999-09-01
120	Expert Affidavit of D. West dated September 1st, 1999	1999-09-02
125	Expert affidavit of M. Ward dated August 30, 1999	1999-09-13
132	Expert rebuttal affidavit of M.R. Ward dated September 14, 1999	1999-09-17
131a	Expert rebuttal affidavit of D. West dated September 14, 1999	1999-10-29
146a	Expert rebuttal affidavit of R. Schwindt, S. Globerman and T. Kemp dated September 5, 1999	1999-10-29
147a	Expert rebuttal affidavit of D West dated September 20, 1999	1999-10-29
128d	Expert rebuttal affidavit of D. Carlton and G. Bamberger dated September 14, 1999	1999-12-03
129a	Expert rebuttal affidavit of D. McFetridge dated September 14, 1999	1999-12-03
135a	Expert rebuttal affidavit of D. Carlton and G. Bamberger dated September 19, 1999	1999-12-03
142b	Expert rebuttal affidavit of D. Carlton and G. Bambergerd dated September 27, 1999	1999-12-03
144a	Expert rebuttal affidavit of S. Cole, C. O'Leary, J. Tuttle and E. Fergin dated October 5, 1999	1999-12-03

Decision(s)

Decision(s)
#	Title	Date
19	Consent Order regarding the amendment of the notice of application and the statement	1998-12-23
28	Order regarding scheduling	1999-02-16
38	Interim confidentiality Order	1999-04-09
59	Order arising from pre-hearing conference on May 25 and 26, 1999: Discovery issues, clarification of the Order regarding scheduling and amendment of response	1999-05-26
54	Order regarding the Commissioner's motion considered at the pre-hearing conference on May 25, 1999: ICG monitor issue, confidentiality issues, confidentiality level of the zip disk and Andrew Carroll's examination	1999-05-27
58	Order amending Order regarding scheduling (exchange of expert affidavits and affidavits in rebuttal and in reply)	1999-05-27
64	Reasons for Order regarding clarification of the Order regarding scheduling	1999-06-09
65	Reason for Order regarding the Commissioner's motion considered at the pre-hearing conference on May 25 and 26, 1999: ICG monitor issue, confidentiality issues, confidentiality level of the zip disk and Andrew Carroll's examination	1999-06-09
71	Order regarding miscellaneous matters considered at the pre-hearing conference on June 16, 1999: Confidentiality designation and access to certain ICG documents and the identification of certain studies	1999-06-16
72	Reasons for Order regarding confidentiality designation and access to certain ICG documents and the identification of certain studies	1999-06-16
96	Order regarding miscellaneous matters considered at the pre-hearing conference on August 19,1999	1999-08-24
97	Reasons and Order regarding production of documents	1999-08-24
107	Clarification to Order regarding miscellaneous matters considered at the pre-hearing conference on August 19,1999	1999-08-30
122	Order arising from pre-hearing conference on September 2 and 7, 1999: confidentiality issues at the hearing, access to expert reports, sworn summaries and subpoena duces tecus	1999-09-08
183	Order regarding a request for adjournment of a motion and other matters	2000-05-19
191	Order and Reasons for Order	2000-05-31
192b	Reasons and Order (final)	2000-08-30
200	Order regarding the Respondents' motion for an Order confirming the termination of the consent interim Order dated December 11, 1998	2000-09-12
201	Order regarding the Commissioner's motion for an Order staying the Decision of the Tribunal dated August 30, 2000	2000-09-12
202	Reasons and Order regarding the Commissioner's motion for an Order staying the Tribunal's Order with respect to section 104 of the Competition Act	2000-09-12
203	Reasons for Order regarding the Commissioner's motion for an Order staying the Order dated August 30, 2000	2000-09-14
204	Reasons for Order regarding the Respondents' motion for an Order confirming the termination of the consent interim Order dated December 11, 1998	2000-09-15
214	Scheduling Order following the response for judgement of the Federal Court of Appeal dated April 4, 2001	2001-05-08
218	Order amending Scheduling Order following the response for judgment of the Federal Court of Appeal dated April 4, 2001	2001-05-17
228	Order amending Scheduling Order dated May 17, 2001	2001-07-10
238a	Reasons and Order following the reasons for judgment of the Federal Court of Appeal dated April 4, 2001	2002-04-04

Proceeding 3 Commissioner of Competition v Superior Propane Inc., ICG Propane Inc., Petro-Canada and The Chancellor Holdings Corporation
Section(s):	ss. 104 (92) - Interim Order (Mergers)
Filed on:	1998-12-10
Status:	Decided: 1998-12-11

Applicant(s):

Commissioner of Competition

Respondent(s):

Superior Propane Inc.

ICG Propane Inc.

Petro-Canada

The Chancellor Holdings Corporation

Hearing Date:	1998-12-11
Hearing Location:	Ottawa
Panel Members:	Rothstein J.

Case Documents

Pleading(s)

Pleading(s)
#	Title	Date
10a	Notice of Application for a consent interim Order under sections 104 and 105 of the Competition Act	1998-12-10
10b	Memorandum of argument (Interim Order)	1998-12-10
10c	Affidavit of John Pecman sworn December 10, 1998	1998-12-10

Decision(s)

Decision(s)
#	Title	Date
13	Consent interim Order	1998-12-11

You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.

Do not display this message anymore